EDITOR'S NOTE: Hello world! This is my first formal review of any piece of music that has made it into the public eye. I wrote it in response to a call for reviews on FestFans, a Google Group for fans of Rhymefest, an emcee out of Chicago. Many of you readers are probably not hip-hop heads, but if you are down, give it a read and tell me if it sounds okay. It is certainly a sincere review, if nothing else. Anyway, thanks, and enjoy!What I've always liked about Rhymefest is his candor. He is unabashedly upfront with his feelings and emotions, which has always made him a compelling figure in hip-hop. At any point, when I hear a wack rapper on the radio or on the Internet, I can hear Fest in my ear, talking with that rapper's mother, simply stating, "ma'am, I don't agree with that decision." But from "Blue Collar," his first wide-distributed LP release, to the present day and beyond, Fest is evolving as an artist, and his latest mixtape, "The Manual" (produced by Scram Jones) shows how Fest has really changed, all the while staying the same.
What's changed? For one, his tone. Songs like "Coolness" and several parts of the "Native Tongues Medley" series show a darker, angrier Che, especially with lines like "I wasn't ever homophobic 'til recently ... y'all confusing Internet buzz for love." These, combined with "SuperSonic (Chucky Cheese)," a slight at Charles Hamilton, show a resentment I have yet to see in Fest. For Rhymefest, the Internet is not a good thing, and neither is the evolving status of hip-hop fashion and attitude.
This translates into what seems like a more "serious" vocal range - gone are many of the shouts and continuous yelling that used to make Fest a fun emcee to hear. That's not to say he is no longer entertaining; this new delivery re-emphasizes the importance of his rhymes, forcing listeners to be serious about hearing his music, rather than allowing themselves to blend his usually more melodic voice into the background.
Fest also delves into a spat of homophobia that was entirely absent from anything we've heard him spit before. Personally, it is a bit disconcerting to hear the profuse use of "faggot" in several of the lines, especially when employed to reinforce such a stale construct of masculinity. Very Eminem circa, "The Marshall Mathers LP," meaning that it comes off as immature.
Even so, Fest seems to actually recognize the fact that he is deliberately using slurs, which makes his use of them more complex. At the beginning of "SuperSonic," he includes an audio clip of him being asked, "But why, when you kick the door down, do you have to trample over women and gay people?" His response is, simply, "Who? Did I trample over gay people?" The use of this clip seems to present Fest's argument that he is not hateful toward gay people, nor does he target them specifically. That does not necessarily exonerate him from his new use of anti-gay slurs, but it definitely adds a complexity that listeners should not be too quick to judge. Like I said, this is Rhymefest doing what he does best: being candid with the public. He is not holding back anything, be it prejudice or support for the various enterprises he encounters. This definitely makes for a more intellectually-stimulating hip-hop record.
In terms of the rest of the songs on the mixtape, Rhymefest continues his socially-conscious streak, with "Pulls Me Back," "Exodus 5.1" and "RNQ." All these songs are strong lyrically, with a "Exodus 5.1" employing a steady repetition of questions that really makes for a thought-provoking experience. This track also harkens back to "Bullet," with a seriously provocative set of topics that makes the listeners consider the state of things as they are. "Pulls Me Back" is notable for its use of the "Africa" synth sample for the beat, which, paired with the struggles described by Fest in the song, makes for an interesting expose on Midwest life during this economic depression.
There is also a bunch of fun songs, including the brilliantly-executed "Rhymefest vs Big Daddy Kane." Using the classic, "Warm It Up Kane," Rhymefest seamlessly weaves his battle rhymes in with those of Kane, and it provides for what is not a bad battle at all (I'd like to actually watch them go at it lyrically). "Party 4 Free" is a nice lyrically journey through a variety of topics, especially with lines like, "Happy Chanukah, I be styling in my yarmulke / On my Yahama, 150 on the speedometer," "Happy Graduation, congratulations / I heard you got a job at a gas station." This song really brings "Brand New" to mind, with Fest on a happier tip, just rhyming away and making fun left and right.
Overall, Rhymefst produces a solid performance with this cut. On his blog, he gave himself 4.5 out of 5 stars; on that scale, I think I have to give it a solid 3.5. In terms of his work to date, I think he is definitely on bar with much of it, but works like "Man In The Mirror" and "Blue Collar" just seem to stand out a bit more in terms of cohesion and entertainment. But this couldn't have been a better appetizer for "El Che," which promises to be his strongest performance to date. Assuming it is ever released.
If you haven't already,
download the mixtape for free from the Rhymefest Store.